This work addresses the growing challenge of contextuality within Christianity in the setting of the vibrant and dynamic Caribbean. The challenge results from the recognition that all religious practices are conditioned by the geographical ethnic socioeconomic and cultural frameworks in which they emerge. This contextuality should inform the way theological diversity within Christianity is addressed as well as the way Christian formulations are considered in relation to other religions. The text offers conceptual support for the position that Christian theologizing in the Caribbean requires that the contexts religious diversity be engaged and that insights from other religions be explored. Processing this position through an examination of religious dynamics within the Englishspeaking subregion the prominent attempt at contextually sensitive Christianity Caribbean Revisionist Christianity with the associated theological orientation Caribbean Theology is analyzed in relation to formulations and practices from other dominant religions in the areaAfroCaribbean Religion Hinduism and Islam. Epistemological analysis exposes the complexity of the religious life and a framework is proposed for interreligious engagement. This framework engenders contextually sensitive pluralism and demands that theology be pursued in dialectical mode. The dialectical approach is then dramatized in an interreligious dialogue on God.